Bechko P. K., PhD in Economics, Professor, Professor of Department of Finances, Banking and Insurance of Uman National University of Horticulture, Uman, Urkaine

ORCID ID: 0000-0003-0928-4778
e-mail: petro19500807@gmail.com

Barabash L. V., PhD in Economics, Associate Professor, Associate Professor of Department of Finances, Banking and Insurance of Uman National University of Horticulture, Uman, Urkaine

ORCID ID: 0000-0002-4836-8950
e-mail: Lesly-z@ukr.net

Lysa N. V., PhD in Economics, Associate Professor, Associate Professor of Department of Finances, Banking and Insurance of Uman National University of Horticulture, Uman, Urkaine

ORCID ID: 0000-0003-0332-3801
e-mail: lisa.nataliya@ukr.net

Tax Benefins as a Tool to Impement
the Concept of Fairness in Taxation

Introduction. In a contemporary economic environment, the issue of improving fairness in taxation still remains unresolved in all countries. In this context, one of the aspects, that is basic and at the same time makes taxation complicated, is tax burden that influences directly the development of the economy of the state. Its fair distribution makes the basis for strengthening the fairness in taxation, which, according to the definition of A.Smith, is one of the four main principles of taxation.

Purpose. Therefore, the question arises as to the detection of efficient tools that will promote the strengthening of the role of the fairness principle in the current taxation system of Ukraine.

Results. Tax Code of Ukraine defines a number of fundamental principles, on which the activity of the national taxation system is based, that characterize and regulate its functioning, considering both the peculiarities of payers and the duties of controlling authorities. The principle of fairness occupies a prominent place among them, though it is identified with the functioning of tax incentives, that appeared independently from the concept “fairness”. Functioning in the current tax system in Ukraine, tax benefits perform two opposite tasks: on the one hand, they destroy formal equity, which the state strives to achieve, on the other hand, it is the tool, that helps to achieve this equity. Applying tax benefits in the case when a tax payer (legal person) is unable to pay taxes or to stimulate priority and problematic spheres and branches of a national economy is one of the prerequisites to create a fair tax system. For natural persons tax benefits are used in case of low paying capacity of certain categories. At present, in Ukraine every tax or levy has a number of benefits, even though their number reduced in 2017 compared to 2010 by 77 benefits, and the share of benefits, cost-intensive for the budget, reduced by 29.9 percentage points, it is impossible to count the efficiency of their functioning. According to the Tax Code of Ukraine, tax benefit is understood as a full and partial exemption of payers from taxes when justified as provided for by the tax legislation. Though at present in Ukraine there are no clear identification features of benefits as an economic phenomenon, they are nevertheless regarded as efficient incentive tool of the activity and behavior of payers. The negative point is the fact that neither in legal documents nor at the scientific and theoretical level there are methods of evaluation of the efficiency of the functioning of tax benefits. Therefore, only the volumes of money, that were not obtained by the budgets of different levels, and the absence or availability of the incentives to carry out the activity by the payers testify their efficiency.

Conclusions. Existing situation in Ukraine in the organization and functioning of tax system, based on the principles of social justice, requires clear definition of the concept “tax benefits” as well as approval of the methodology, that defines the efficiency of their functioning. Elucidation of the outlined issues will promote the rational and substantiated use of benefits in taxation process and stimulate the reduction of inequity among taxpayers.

Keywords: tax; benefit; tax benefit; fairness; taxation principle.

References:

1. Balitska, V. (2011). Sotsialna spravedlyvist opodatkuvannia kriz pryzmu platospromozhnosti subiektiv ekonomiky Ukrainy [Social justice of taxation in terms of paying capacity of business entities of Ukraine]. Financy Ukrainy – Finances of Ukraine, 9, 33-44 [in Ukrainian].
2. State Fiscal Service of Ukraine (2011). Dovidnyk pilh No. 56/1 ta No. 56/2, nadanykh chynnym zakonodavstvom po splati podatkiv ta zboriv stanom na: 01.01.2011 r. [Directory of tax benefits No. 56/1 and No. 56/2 provided by the current legislation on tax and fees payments as of 01.01.2011]. Retrieved from: http://sfs.gov.ua/dovidniki–reestri–perelik/dovidniki-/54005.html [in Ukrainian].
3. State Fiscal Service of Ukraine (2012). Dovidnyk pilh No. 60/1 ta No. 60/2, nadanykh chynnym zakonodavstvom po splati podatkiv ta zboriv stanom na: 01.01.2012 r. [Directory of tax benefits No. 60/1 and No. 60/2 provided by the current legislation on tax and fees payments as of 01.01.2012]. Retrieved from: http://sfs.gov.ua/dovidniki–reestri–perelik/dovidniki-/54005.html [in Ukrainian].
4. State Fiscal Service of Ukraine (2013). Dovidnyk pilh No. 64/1 ta No. 64/2, nadanykh chynnym zakonodavstvom po splati podatkiv ta zboriv stanom na: 01.01.2013 r. [Directory of tax benefits No. 64/1 and No. 64/2 provided by the current legislation on tax and fees payments as of 01.01.2013]. Retrieved from: http://sfs.gov.ua/dovidniki–reestri–perelik/dovidniki-/54005.html [in Ukrainian].
5. State Fiscal Service of Ukraine (2014). Dovidnyk pilh No. 69/1 ta No. 69/2, nadanykh chynnym zakonodavstvom po splati podatkiv ta zboriv stanom na: 01.01.2014 r. [Directory of tax benefits No. 69/1 and No. 69/2 provided by the current legislation on tax and fees payments as of 01.01.2014]. Retrieved from: http://sfs.gov.ua/dovidniki–reestri–perelik/dovidniki-/54005.html [in Ukrainian].
6. State Fiscal Service of Ukraine (2015). Dovidnyk pilh No. 73/1 ta No. 73/2, nadanykh chynnym zakonodavstvom po splati podatkiv ta zboriv stanom na: 01.01.2015 r. [Directory of tax benefits No. 73/1 and No. 73/2 provided by the current legislation on tax and fees payments as of 01.01.2015]. Retrieved from: http://sfs.gov.ua/dovidniki–reestri–perelik/dovidniki-/54005.html [in Ukrainian].
7. Dovidnyk No. 77/1 ta No. 77/2 inshykh podatkovykh pilh stanom na 01.01.2016 [Directory of other tax benefits No. 77/1 and No. 77/2 as of 01.01.2016]. Retrieved from: https://buhgalter.com.ua/dovidnik/dovidniki-podatkovih-pilg/dovidnik-podatkovih-pilg2/ [in Ukrainian].
8. Dovidnyk No. 81/1 ta No. 81/2 inshykh podatkovykh pilh stanom na 31.12.2016 [Directory of other tax benefits No. 81/1 and No. 81/2 as of 31.12.2016]. Retrieved from: https://buhgalter.com.ua/dovidnik/dovidniki-podatkovih-pilg/dovidnik-podatkovih-pilg2/ [in Ukrainian].
9. State Fiscal Service of Ukraine (2017). Dovidnyk No. 85/1 ta No. 85/2 podatkovykh pilh, shcho ye vtratamy dokhodiv biudzhetu stanom na12.2017 [Directory of tax benefits that are the losses of the budget revenue No. 85/1 and 85/2 as of 31.12.2017. Retrieved from: http://sfs.gov.ua/dovidniki– reestri–perelik/dovidniki-/54005.htm [in Ukrainian].
10. Mayburov, I., Sokolovskaya, A. (2001). Teoriya nalogooblozheniya. Prodvinutyy kurs [Theory of taxation. Advanced course]. Moscow: UNITYDANA [in Russ.].
11. Verhovna Rada of Ukraine (2010). Tax Code of Ukraine (Act No. 2755, December, 2). Retrieved from https://buhgalter911.com/normativnaya-baza/nalogovyi-kodeks [in Ukrainian].
12. John Rawls. A Theory of Justice. Retrieved from: https://gtmarket.ru/laboratory/basis/6642.
13. Gruber, J. Measuring the Fairness of Tax Systems. Taxation in Theory and Practice, IV, 532–535. Retrieved from: http://www.ase.ro/upcpr/profesori/758/Scan_Gruber_Fairness%20of%20Taxation.pdf
14. Smit, A. (2014). Issledovanie o prirode i prichinakh bogatstva narodov. Moskva: Lamartis.
15. Smith, A. (1937). An Inquiry into the Nature and Cause of the Wealth of Nations. Modern Library Edition. New York: Random House.
16. Stanley, Surrey Pathways to Tax Reform. The Concept of Tax Expenditures. Retrieved from http://www.hup.harvard.edu/catalog.php?isbn=9780674436503.